Performance and development reviews are a key element in helping your employees grow and succeed in their roles. Regular, well-structured reviews provide the perfect opportunity to guide your team, align their goals with the company’s vision, and foster a culture of feedback. Done correctly, performance reviews are a vital tool in driving both individual and organisational success.
Why Regular Reviews Matter
Think of a performance review as your team’s GPS—it helps everyone stay on track. Regular reviews keep your employees engaged and give them the chance to set clear, achievable goals. These check-ins help identify any issues early on, so there’s time to correct course. It also creates an open environment where employees feel their contributions are recognised, and they understand exactly where they stand within the company.
A regular review system provides the opportunity for continuous improvement and clearer growth trajectories. By keeping the conversation going, employees feel more supported, and their individual development is better aligned with the company’s strategic goals.
Creating a Feedback Culture
The most successful organisations are those that foster a feedback culture. These businesses focus on creating a space for honest, constructive, and ongoing feedback. A feedback culture promotes trust and transparency, helping employees feel more confident and motivated.
Research shows that that feedback-rich environments boost employee engagement and performance levels. When employees receive constructive feedback regularly, they’re not just learning how to improve—they’re actively engaging with the process of improvement.
The rise of continuous feedback in performance management is a major trend shaping the future of reviews. Supplementing the traditional annual performance reviews, businesses are now engaging in frequent check-ins. Research from Deloitte highlights that employees who receive regular feedback are significantly more engaged in their work and more likely to perform at a high level (Deloitte, 2024).
When feedback is given regularly, it feels more relevant and can be actioned on immediately. For instance, if an employee is excelling in customer service, they’ll know about it in real time, and managers can provide suggestions on how to further improve or adjust in other areas. Employees feel seen, heard, and valued, which ultimately leads to increased job satisfaction and better performance outcomes.
Modern Approaches to Reviews: The Shift Away from Scoring Systems
In the past, many organisations used number-based systems—like giving employees a score from 1 to 5—to measure performance. But research shows these scores often don’t give a full picture. Employees can feel confused or demotivated when their work is summed up with a single number. In contrast, narrative reviews take a more personal and detailed approach. A study in the Harvard Business Review found that open, conversation-style reviews help employees understand what they’re doing well and where they can improve. These types of reviews are more meaningful and motivating because they offer real feedback, not just a rating.
As performance reviews continue to evolve, there’s a clear shift toward more personalised and growth-focused approaches. Instead of just scoring people, many organisations now help staff create development plans tailored to their goals. When employees feel supported in their career growth, they’re more likely to stay with the company.
This move away from rigid scores towards development-centered reviews allows employees to explore their aspirations, set realistic goals, and receive guidance on how to achieve them. The modern approach to performance reviews is less about ‘passing’ or ‘failing’ and more about how employees can grow and contribute to the company’s success over time.
What if You’re a Small Business?
As a small business, you may think that performance reviews aren’t necessary, especially if you have a smaller team or you’re working closely with your employees every day. However, regular performance and development reviews are just as important—if not more so—when you’re running a small business. A clear structure for feedback can help set expectations, improve employee engagement, and give your team the direction they need to grow with the business.
In small businesses, performance reviews may not need to be as formal or frequent as in larger organisations, but the concept still applies. You can make them more personal, focusing on individual goals and achievements. Many small business owners use informal, one-on-one check-ins, which can be just as effective in fostering a culture of growth and continuous feedback. Even a 15-minute conversation every few months can go a long way in helping employees understand their value to the business and how they can improve. Investing in performance reviews, even on a smaller scale, can lead to higher employee retention, improved job satisfaction, and better business outcomes.
For More Information
Deloitte. (2024). The rise of continuous feedback: How regular reviews drive employee engagement and performance. Retrieved from https://www.deloitte.com
Harvard Business Review (HBR). (2016). Why Managers Struggle with Performance Reviews: Preparing for Difficult Conversations. Harvard Business Review. Retrieved from https://hbr.org
Harvard Business Review (HBR). (2024). Research: Performance Reviews That Actually Motivate Employees. Harvard Business Review. Retrieved from https://hbr.org
Bersin, J. (2017). The Importance of Employee Development: How Fostering Career Growth Improves Retention. Bersin by Deloitte. Retrieved from https://www.bersin.com
Need Advice?
ER Strategies are experts in employment compliance and can assist you in managing your employment compliance responsibilities. To discuss your obligations and assistance we can provide, get in touch with us at 1300 55 66 37, or click the button below.
